Globe & Mail Series on Child Care

Globe and Mail 

In October 2013, The Globe & Mail did an unprecedented series on child care in Canada including six major articles, supplementary articles and commentaries. This series focuses on  building a better daycare system in Canada.

Since the series, The Globe & Mail has kept up their coverage - here are recent articles, followed by the full series.

 Safe and affordable daycare starts with better policy -Mar 17, 2014 safe_and_afforable_daycare_needs_policy.JPG
"Federal, provincial, and municipal governments must immediately prioritize childcare, and provide funding for additional licenced care facilities. Parents are struggling to find childcare solutions for tomorrow, never mind next year."

Nightmare? I want a daycare on Elm Street- Mar 3, 2014

“You know what should lurch back from the dead? A safe, affordable, universal daycare plan, that’s what.”  Elizabeth Renzetti shares an opinion piece on the need for affordable child care, not income splitting.

 Regulate unlicensed daycares, but keep a light touch- Mar 2, 2014

Globe and Mail Editorial- "Home daycares provide a vital service, offering parents a convenient, cost-effective alternative to their licensed counterparts, which are typically more expensive and where space is in short supply. It is precisely because so many families choose this option – 80 per cent of children in daycare are at unregulated facilities – that government should take a closer look at how they operate, to see if there are any risks they pose to children’s welfare."


Child care: Why Canada needsWhy_Canada.jpg to do better at helping all families- Nov 14, 2013

Globe and Mail’s Erin Anderssen discusses why Canadian families need the federal government to adopt more “forward-thinking family policy”, that will allow for Canadians to balance raising a family and their budget.

The article explores the economic importance of affordable, accessible child care in an aging population, and the values policy should reflect in order to support equity of all Canadian families.


There’s no need to fear a national child care program- Nov 13 2013

The Globe and Mail’s comprehensive series on child care “sketched a bleak picture for families across Canada” and reinforced the need for a national child care program.

Child care researchers Jane  and Martha Friendly is director and Professors Susan Prentice  and Linda White speak on the importance of a national child care program that  offers “high quality services including parenting programs for parents staying at home with young children, part-day nursery schools, centres and regulated home childcare.”


Better_daycare_for__7day.jpgBetter daycare for $7/day: One province's solution for Canada -Oct 19 2013

Child care for $7/day? Our neighbouring province Quebec is showing the country how an affordable child care system can be built. With Quebec’s child care costing families an average of $140 a month, Ontario families spend about $900 or more.

“To deliver a one-fee system, Quebec now invests $2.2-billion a year in its childcare strategy, nearly two-thirds of the $3.6-billion spent by all provinces and territories combined“

Not only has Quebec established affordable prices for child care but this investment has “decreased poverty, increased mobility for mothers and produced more babies among all income brackets.”

 Video: Lessons the rest of Canada should learn from PEI's daycare overhaul  -Oct 19 2013

Lessons_the_rest_of_Canada_should_learn_from_PEI.jpgPrince Edward Island has made the changes to the child care system and invested in early learning. Anne Miller, supervisor of Early Learning Academy addresses the changes PEI has made which include:

-Better wages
-Subsidized funding
-Certification for staff
-Engage parents
-Holistic Approach to the community

Take a moment to click the title to watch the video.

The_case_for_publicly_funded_child_care_in_Canada.jpgThe case for publicly funded child care in Canada -Oct 20 2013

The need for more publicly funded child care in Canada is needed now more than ever, especially when building a better child care system in Canada.  However, Prime Minister Stephen Harper believes the taxable Universal Child Care Benefit of $100 a month is sufficient for parents “to decide how to care for their kids”. Working parents searching for child care know that they cannot find child care for anywhere close to $100 a month.

According to a study by the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development Canada’s upper-income families with two working parents pay, on average 18 per cent of their net income on child care expenses. For low-income, single-parent families, 48 per cent of their net income is used.

 The evolution in public policy surrounding child care -Oct 20 2013

The_evolution_in_public_policy_surrounding_child_care.jpgThe public policy surrounding child care as evolved since the mid 1800’s, where child was a “welfare service” for parents and nuns created the first child care centre to assist working mothers.

Second World War- The federal government offered to split the cost of child care with provinces so women can contribute to the war effort.
1950’s - Most mothers stayed home
1970’s- The Royal Commission on the Status of Women called for a public program as a positive step toward greater gender equality.
2001-A significant change in policy with the expansion of parental-leave benefits.
2005-Federal Liberals came close to signing an agreement with the provinces to create “a truly national system of early learning and care”—committing $5 billion over four years
2006- Federal Conservation Party under Stephen Harpers government canceled the national plan and created the Universal Child Care Benefit which pays families $100 a month for every child under 6—estimated cost over seven years= $17.5 billion

How much does Ottawa current spend on early learning? $2.6 billion a year

We want children, but can’t afford daycare -Oct 21want_children.jpg 2013

With the high cost of child care, families across Canada are in the dilemma of wanting to have more children, but are discouraged because they simply cannot affordable child care.

 In 1990, “47 per cent of women between 20 and 24 indicated that they planned to have three or more children”, however that family expectation has shrunk to an average of 25.5 per cent of women raising three children.

Marina Adshade states “45 per cent of women [in their twenties] say they want to have two children and another 35 per cent say they want more… but my guess is that unless they have access to affordable childcare, the majority of Canadian women will continue to have fewer children than they hope”.

 The procreative class: How cities can help on the child-care front -Oct 22 2013

The_procreative_class.jpg“In Canada, only Ontario mandates that municipalities play a role, which includes providing some of the financing and managing the overall budget…” however, cities rely on provinces for funding, and “without incentives or regulations, expanding in big cities is difficult”.

So what is the current child care situation like in major cities?

OTTAWA- Has a central registration list for child-care centres with 10,290 families on the list. Fees = $69 for an infant, $56 for a toddler and $40 for a preschooler.

CALGARY- Does not track waiting lists but the University of Calgary Child Care Centre has 370 children waiting.
Fees=The Y charges a flat rate of $925 a month for care but some parents pay between $1,000 and $1,500 for city child care.

WINNIPEG: Waiting list is at 6,510 families.
Fees= $30 a day for infants, $20 for a preschooler and less than half of that for school-aged care.

 VANCOUVER: Fees= under $1,200/month for toddlers. For poor families, the maximum subsidy for a toddler space is only $635 – which means they still have come up with, on average, another $560

TORONTO: Waiting list is at 19,000  families as of July
Fees= between $62 and $95 a day for an infant, and $36 and $65 for a toddler.

 Desperate parents forced into 'grey market' of unlicensed daycare -Oct 23 2013
In Canada there is only has enough regulated centre-based spots for about one-fifth of children under the age of five, forcing families to rely on unlicensed child care where they are “leaving their children with caregivers who may not even have first-aid training, paying whatever is asked, and hoping for the best.”

However, too often we have seen children die in unlicensed care, with the recent death of two year old in Vaughan, where 27 children registered. In December 2012, two year old Jeremie Audette drowned in a backyard pool, while at a “play date” with 31 children.

“There are no doubt many excellent unlicensed caregivers, but aside from word of mouth, parents have no way to identify them. Even when they do their best due diligence, says Alain Audette, Jeremie’s father, “You don’t really know who is looking after your kids.”

 What the world can teach Canada about building better daycare -Oct 24 2013

What_the_world_can_teach_Canada.jpgIf Canada needs pointers on how to build a better child care system for families, they can take a look at some of the countries who have taken the initiative for an affordable, accessible system.

Sweden- A universal, affordable, educational system with the cost of care at about $300 a month. Preschool is free for four and five year olds and almost every child is cared for by both parents at least until their first birthday because of generous parental leave.

Waiting lists- municipalities are required by law to find a space within three months.

Portugal: “Elementary schools are required to operate for a full day, from 9 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. If care is needed out those hours there is additional state-funded care before and after school, with fees based on income.”

Norway:  “To increase the participation of men, Norway has set targets, along with extra support for male educators, job advertising and recruiting campaigns targeting them.”

Slovenia: “Developed a universal child-care system that is run by municipalities, which are required to create enough spaces. Families pay an average of $460 a month for a toddler, but only one-third as much for a sibling – and no charge for the third child.”

Japan: “Co-ordinated the construction of privately managed child centres in such places as train stations, so commuters need not travel to the suburbs in search of care.”

Australia: “Created a national quality standard that has been adopted by every state and territory and applies to all forms of child care. Centres are graded from “excellent” to “significant improvement required,” and the results must be displayed in the centre and online.”

New Zealand: “All early-childhood educators are trained to follow New Zealand’s national curriculum, called Te Whariki, which means “woven mat.” Implemented in 2002, it teaches through play and is designed to create a seamless transition into school.”

 Preschool is more than babysitting – it’s education -Oct 24 2013Preschool_is_more_than.jpg

Here, teaching based on play. Supervisor Lorraine McIntosh comments on children playing a card game version of Seven-Up.

She says “ they think they’re just playing a game but really what they are doing is recognizing their numbers and learning to take turns.”

 “We get really irate when we hear the word babysitting,” Ms. McIntosh says. It’s education, she adds.

 Young families struggling with two huge expenses: housing and daycare - Oct 24 2013

Young_families_struggling.jpgRob Carrick speaks on the financial pressures of juggling the cost of housing and the cost of children. Rob says "daycare is the hidden menace, financially.

It’s amazing that such a massive cost gets so little mention outside gatherings of cash-poor parents".

One study estimates monthly average costs for infants range from $1,152 in Ontario, $631 in Manitoba and $152 in Quebec.

 What_PEI_and_Quebec_can_teach.jpgWhat PEI and Quebec can teach the rest of Canada about improving child care -Oct 25 2013

Every great child care system started with a 1st step. The Globe and Mail outlines 10 tips on how provinces can get started on improving the child care system.

We don’t all need to imitate Quebec on daycare -Oct 25 2013

This editorial in the Globe and Mail is critical of the federal government and pushes provinces to develop child care programs to meet need of families.Flawed editorial called for more provincial experiments while people want national child care.

 To lower inequality, boost spending on early childhood education - Oct 25 2013

To_lower_inequality.jpgCraig Alexander, senior vice-president and chief economist of TD Bank Group focuses on the importance in investing in affordable, high quality child care and the benefits of early learning on young children.

Alexander also calls on “more investment in high equality early childhood education and better access for such services for low and middle income Canadians. ”

talking_point.jpgThis week’s Talking Point – the daycare dilemma – and other letters to the editor -Oct 26 2013

Great perspectives from Canadian families, here is their personal opinion/feedback from discussion generated by the Globe and Mail Series on child care.

Also, take a moment to read Trevor Finn’s article “We earn more than $100,000 a year. Why can't we afford daycare?“ which was published in July 2013.